Friday, July 6, 2012

Daughters of the Witching Hill by Mary Sharratt.

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

"The said Elizabeth Southerns [alias Demdike] confesseth, and sayth; that about twenty years past, as she was coming homeward from begging, there met her near unto a stonepit in Gouldshey, in the said Forrest of Pendle, a spirit or devil in the shape of a boy, the one half of his coat black, and the other brown, who bade her stay, saying to her, that if she would give him her soul, she should have any thing that she would request." - Thomas Pott's in The Wonderfull Discoverie of Witches in the Countie of Lancaster, 1613

Daughters of the Witching Hill by Mary Sharratt is an historical novel based around events as recorded at the Pendle Witch Trials in Lancashire, England, in the year 1612. England at this time was under the rule of King James I and Catholicism was outlawed. As such, Papists were forced to practice their faith in secret and anyone caught doing so was tried by the local magistrate. James I also had a particular dislike of witches and declared that anyone suspected of practicing witchcraft should be prosecuted.

Daughters of the Witching Hill tells the story of these witches - some herbalists, others Papists - from the point of view of Elizabeth Southerns (Demdike) and her grand-daughter, Alizon Device. However, it is not a book on the trials per se, but rather a fictional account of the lives of the women at the forefront of the 1612 trials.

The story begins with Demdike as the narrator, who tells how she came to be in possession of the knowledge, skills and power to heal the sick through her relationship with a familiar spirit. She is able to provide a living for herself and her family through the provision of these services and goes on to teach her grandchildren in the way of her craft. However, her grand-daughter, Alizon, yearns to be normal and resents her magics for the fear they instill in other people. Yet when she is offended by a travelling pedler, her harsh words become a curse and from there begins the infamous Lancashire witchtrials of 1612.

Daughters of the Witching Hill provides an interesting insight into what life may have been like for those herbalists, midwives, cunning men and women, and even Papists who were accused of witchcraft during the 15th and 16th centuries, and of how even a seemingly small and innocent occurance can leave a permanent mark on the pages of history. Daughters of the Witching Hill gives voice to those women who are often regarded as some of the most feared and ruthless witches of all time.

I liked that the author decided to write this novel in first-person narrative from the points of view of two of the accused, however I think the story would have provided an even greater insight had Anne Whittle (Chattox) also been given a voice. Having lived her entire life on the fringes of society and being feared for a witch long before Demdike and Alizon Device, I cannot help but feel somewhat disappointed that her perspective is missing from this novel. However, for someone with a keen interest in the Pendle Witches (they are my favourite witches in history, afterall), I found Daughters of the Witching Hill to be a passionate re-telling of one of history's darkest and most intriguing moments.


  1. Thank you so much for your kind review!

    Out of curiousity, where did you find out about Daughters of the Witching Hill?

    Lovely blog!

    All good wishes,

    1. Hi Mary,

      Many thanks for taking the time to visit my blog and leave a message. It was such a lovely surprise!

      Now to answer your question (and then some), I first found out about Daughters of the Witching Hill way back in 2010 on Goodreads. I was so excited to learn that someone had written on the Pendle Witches! I tried to win copies but had no luck. :( And I was so overwhelmed by Mt TBR that it had to stay on my wishlist for much long than I intended. In the end it was a friend who was kind enough to gift me her copy, knowing how much I am intrigued by the Pendle witchtrials, and it went straight to the top of my reading list - The timing of which I find somewhat poetic considering that it is 400 years since the trials this August.

      I have discovered that you have blogs where there appears to be writings on Demdike and the like, so now I must read them - and hope that there will be other novels like Daughters of the Witching Hill in the future. ;)

      Kind Regards,


Thank you for taking the time to visit my blog. I really appreciate any suggestions, feedback and comments you may like to share, so please don't be afraid to leave them. It'd be wonderful to see you return again!